LAtkinson's blog

May 2019 License-Discuss Summary

In May, the License-Discuss mailing list talked about:

  • relationship between the License-Review mailing list and the License Comittee
  • evolution of the license review process
  • comprehensiveness of the approved license list
  • licenses of licenses
  • would three licenses be enough?
  • email threading

April 2019 License-Review Summary

In April, the License-Review mailing list saw extensive debate on the Cryptographic Autonomy License, in particular:

  • its user data clause, and how it affects user freedom
  • obligations placed on the software operator
  • API copyright
  • strategic concerns for the OSI
  • public performance rights for software

March 2019 License-Review Summary

In March, the License-Review mailing list saw the retraction of the SSPL from review, and discussed a set of GPLv3 Additional Terms.

The License-Discuss list (summarized at https://opensource.org/LicenseDiscuss032019) was far more active. Among other things, it discussed Van Lindberg's upcoming Cryptographic Autonomy License, and saw extensive discussion about the license review process: whether the conduct of the list is appropriate, whether there might be alternatives to using email, and whether PEP-style summaries would help.

March 2019 License-Discuss Summary

In March, the License-Discuss mailing list discussed:

  • the Cryptographic Autonomy License
    • its interactions with the GDPR
    • how public performance applies to software
  • the License-Review process
    • views on tone and conduct on the list
    • the list's role in the license review process
    • problems with email, and alternative tools
    • whether a PEP-style process might help
  • whether licenses should be drafted without legal assistance
  • and more

January 2019 License-Review Summary

In January, the License-Review mailing list discussed:

  • the new license review process
  • Server Side Public License, Version 2 (SSPL v2)
  • Convertible Free Software License, Version 1.3 (C-FSL v1.3)
    • What are the problems with Original Authors?
    • How is the C-FSL different from CLAs or permissive licenses?
    • Why is the publication requirement a problem?
    • Can the C-FSL be OSI-approved?
  • Convertible Free Software License, Version 1.4 (C-FSL v1.4)

January 2019 License-Discuss Summary

In January, the License-Discuss mailing list discussed:

  • the opensource.dev info site
  • Open Data
  • “intimacy” in Open Source licenses
    • process and interface boundaries
    • corresponding Source
    • is it a problem that the FSF introduced a new word?
    • making sense of the law, and bright lines
    • licensor expectations
  • relicensing and maintainer–community dynamics
  • VanL's upcoming copyleft license

Pages

Subscribe to RSS - LAtkinson's blog